Security

Supply Chain Security in Code Review: Dependency Analysis Best Practices

Tony Dong
June 1, 2025
13 min read
Share:
Featured image for: Supply Chain Security in Code Review: Dependency Analysis Best Practices

Supply chain attacks have become one of the most sophisticated and dangerous threats to modern software development. From SolarWinds to CodeCov, attackers are increasingly targeting the dependencies, tools, and infrastructure that developers trust every day. This comprehensive guide covers how to build robust supply chain security through strategic code review processes, dependency analysis, and proactive threat detection.

Key Takeaways

  • Supply chain attacks increased 650%: Malicious packages and compromised dependencies are now the #4 attack vector, requiring systematic review processes.
  • SBOM generation is critical: Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) tracking enables rapid vulnerability response and compliance with emerging regulations.
  • Automated scanning prevents 90% of known vulnerabilities: Combining static analysis with dependency scanning catches most supply chain threats before deployment.

Understanding Supply Chain Attack Vectors

Supply chain attacks target the complex web of dependencies, tools, and infrastructure that modern applications rely on. Understanding these attack vectors is essential for developing effective review processes that can detect and prevent compromise.

Common Supply Chain Attack Methods

🚫 High-Risk Attack Vectors

  • • Malicious package injection (typosquatting)
  • • Compromised legitimate packages
  • • Dependency confusion attacks
  • • Build system compromise
  • • Developer tool backdoors
  • • Third-party service breaches
  • • Code signing certificate theft
  • • Repository takeover attacks

✅ Defense Mechanisms

  • • Package integrity verification
  • • Dependency pinning and lock files
  • • Private package repositories
  • • Multi-factor authentication
  • • Code signing validation
  • • Continuous vulnerability scanning
  • • SBOM generation and tracking
  • • Zero-trust build pipelines

⚠️ Supply Chain Security Mindset

Trust but verify everything in your dependency chain. Every third-party package, tool, and service is a potential entry point for attackers. Design your review process to systematically validate all external components.

Dependency Analysis in Code Review

Effective dependency analysis during code review requires a systematic approach to evaluating new dependencies, monitoring existing ones, and maintaining visibility into your complete dependency tree.

New Dependency Review Process

📋 Essential Dependency Review Checklist

Package Legitimacy: Verify package name, publisher, and download statistics
Maintenance Status: Check last update, issue response time, and active development
Security History: Review CVE database and security advisories
License Compliance: Ensure license compatibility with your project
Dependency Tree: Analyze transitive dependencies and potential conflicts
Alternative Assessment: Consider if functionality could be implemented internally

Package Manager Security Configuration

📦 NPM Security Best Practices

# .npmrc - Secure NPM configuration
# Enable package-lock to ensure consistent installs
package-lock=true

# Audit automatically and fail on high severity
audit-level=high

# Verify package signatures
verify-signatures=true

# Use private registry for internal packages
@mycompany:registry=https://npm.internal.company.com

# Disable automatic dependency updates
save-exact=true

# Enable fund reporting for awareness
fund=true

🐍 Python pip Security Configuration

# pip.conf - Secure pip configuration
[global]
# Only install from trusted hosts
trusted-host = pypi.org
              files.pythonhosted.org
              pypi.python.org

# Require HTTPS
require-virtualenv = true
verify-signatures = true

# Use hash checking for reproducible installs
hash-checking-mode = strict

[install]
# Don't install dependencies automatically
no-deps = false
# Require confirmation for installs
user = false

Software Bill of Materials (SBOM) Implementation

SBOM generation provides complete visibility into your software supply chain, enabling rapid vulnerability response and regulatory compliance. Modern development workflows should generate and maintain SBOMs automatically.

SBOM Generation Tools and Integration

🔧 SBOM Generation Tools

  • SPDX Tools: Industry-standard SBOM format
  • CycloneDX: Security-focused SBOM generation
  • Syft: Container and filesystem analysis
  • FOSSA: Commercial SBOM management
  • Tern: Container layer analysis
  • OSS Index: Sonatype vulnerability data

📊 SBOM Integration Points

  • Build Pipeline: Generate SBOM on every build
  • Container Registry: Attach SBOM to container images
  • Release Process: Include SBOM in release artifacts
  • Deployment: Validate SBOM against security policies
  • Monitoring: Track SBOM changes over time
  • Compliance: Generate reports for audits

Automated SBOM Workflow Example

# GitHub Actions workflow for SBOM generation
name: Generate and Validate SBOM

on: [push, pull_request]

jobs:
  sbom-generation:
    runs-on: ubuntu-latest
    steps:
      - uses: actions/checkout@v3
      
      - name: Generate SBOM with Syft
        run: |
          curl -sSfL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/anchore/syft/main/install.sh | sh -s -- -b /usr/local/bin
          syft . -o spdx-json=sbom.spdx.json
      
      - name: Vulnerability Scan with Grype
        run: |
          curl -sSfL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/anchore/grype/main/install.sh | sh -s -- -b /usr/local/bin  
          grype sbom:sbom.spdx.json --fail-on high
      
      - name: Upload SBOM Artifact
        uses: actions/upload-artifact@v3
        with:
          name: sbom
          path: sbom.spdx.json
      
      - name: Compare SBOM Changes
        run: |
          if [ -f previous-sbom.spdx.json ]; then
            echo "Comparing SBOM changes..."
            diff previous-sbom.spdx.json sbom.spdx.json || echo "SBOM changes detected"
          fi
      
      - name: Store SBOM for Future Comparison
        run: cp sbom.spdx.json previous-sbom.spdx.json

Vulnerability Scanning and Management

Continuous vulnerability scanning is essential for maintaining supply chain security. Effective scanning combines multiple data sources and integrates seamlessly into development workflows.

Multi-Source Vulnerability Detection

Vulnerability SourceCoverageUpdate FrequencyIntegration Tools
National Vulnerability DatabaseComprehensive CVE coverageDailyNIST API, CVE feeds
GitHub Security AdvisoriesPackage-specific vulnerabilitiesReal-timeDependabot, GitHub API
Snyk Vulnerability DatabaseCommercial vulnerability intelligenceDailySnyk CLI, IDE plugins
OSS Index (Sonatype)Open source component intelligenceWeeklyREST API, Maven plugins

Vulnerability Triage and Response

🚨 Critical Vulnerabilities (CVSS 9.0-10.0)

  • Response Time: Immediate (within 4 hours)
  • Action: Emergency patch or disable affected components
  • Communication: Notify security team and stakeholders
  • Testing: Automated security regression tests

⚠️ High Vulnerabilities (CVSS 7.0-8.9)

  • Response Time: Within 24 hours
  • Action: Schedule patch in next release cycle
  • Mitigation: Implement temporary workarounds if needed
  • Review: Assess if component can be replaced

📊 Medium/Low Vulnerabilities (CVSS 0.1-6.9)

  • Response Time: Next planned maintenance window
  • Action: Include fixes in regular update cycle
  • Tracking: Monitor for escalation or exploit development
  • Documentation: Record decisions for future reference

Dependency Pinning and Lock File Management

Proper dependency pinning prevents unexpected updates that could introduce vulnerabilities or break functionality. Lock files provide reproducible builds and enable precise vulnerability tracking.

Lock File Best Practices

✅ Effective Lock File Management

  • • Commit lock files to version control
  • • Use exact versions for security-critical dependencies
  • • Regular lock file updates with security review
  • • Automated lock file validation in CI
  • • Separate lock files for different environments
  • • Monitor lock file changes in code reviews

❌ Common Lock File Mistakes

  • • Ignoring lock files in version control
  • • Using ranges instead of exact versions
  • • Automated updates without security review
  • • Inconsistent lock files across environments
  • • Not validating lock file integrity
  • • Bypassing lock files in production builds

Dependency Update Strategies

# Dependabot configuration for controlled updates
# .github/dependabot.yml

version: 2
updates:
  # Security updates - immediate
  - package-ecosystem: "npm"
    directory: "/"
    schedule:
      interval: "daily"
    open-pull-requests-limit: 5
    allow:
      - dependency-type: "direct"
        update-type: "security"
    
  # Regular updates - weekly review  
  - package-ecosystem: "npm"
    directory: "/"
    schedule:
      interval: "weekly"
      day: "monday"
    open-pull-requests-limit: 3
    allow:
      - dependency-type: "direct"
        update-type: "minor"
    ignore:
      # Major updates require manual review
      - dependency-name: "*"
        update-types: ["major"]
    
  # Development dependencies - monthly
  - package-ecosystem: "npm"
    directory: "/"
    schedule:
      interval: "monthly"
    allow:
      - dependency-type: "development"
    labels:
      - "dependencies"
      - "dev-dependencies"

License Compliance and Legal Review

License compliance is a critical but often overlooked aspect of supply chain security. Incompatible licenses can create legal risks and force costly rewrites of critical functionality.

License Risk Assessment Framework

✅ Low Risk Licenses

  • • MIT License
  • • Apache 2.0
  • • BSD 2/3-Clause
  • • ISC License
  • • Unlicense

⚠️ Medium Risk Licenses

  • • LGPL 2.1/3.0
  • • Mozilla Public License
  • • Eclipse Public License
  • • Creative Commons
  • • Artistic License

🚫 High Risk Licenses

  • • GPL 2.0/3.0
  • • AGPL 3.0
  • • SSPL (Server Side Public License)
  • • Custom/Proprietary
  • • Unknown/No License

Automated License Scanning

# License compliance checking with license-checker
npm install -g license-checker

# Generate license report
license-checker --onlyAllow 'MIT;Apache-2.0;BSD-2-Clause;BSD-3-Clause;ISC' \
                --excludePrivatePackages \
                --output json > license-report.json

# Check for problematic licenses
license-checker --failOn 'GPL;AGPL;LGPL;SSPL' \
                --excludePrivatePackages

# Generate SBOM with license information
syft . -o spdx-json --output sbom-with-licenses.spdx.json

# Custom license validation script
cat > validate-licenses.js << 'EOF'
const fs = require('fs');
const report = JSON.parse(fs.readFileSync('license-report.json'));

const bannedLicenses = ['GPL', 'AGPL', 'LGPL', 'SSPL'];
const reviewRequired = ['Creative Commons', 'Custom'];

let violations = [];
let reviewNeeded = [];

Object.entries(report).forEach(([package, details]) => {
  const license = details.licenses;
  
  if (bannedLicenses.some(banned => license.includes(banned))) {
    violations.push({package, license});
  }
  
  if (reviewRequired.some(review => license.includes(review))) {
    reviewNeeded.push({package, license});
  }
});

if (violations.length > 0) {
  console.error('License violations found:', violations);
  process.exit(1);
}

if (reviewNeeded.length > 0) {
  console.warn('Licenses requiring review:', reviewNeeded);
}
EOF

node validate-licenses.js

Private Package Repository Security

Private package repositories provide additional security by allowing organizations to control their dependency supply chain and implement custom security policies.

Private Registry Benefits and Implementation

🔒 Private Registry Security Benefits

  • Package Vetting: Only approved packages are available
  • Version Control: Lock specific versions organization-wide
  • Custom Scanning: Apply organization-specific security policies
  • Air-Gap Deployment: Support offline or restricted environments
  • Compliance: Meet regulatory requirements for software supply chain

🏗️ Implementation Options

Commercial Solutions:

  • • JFrog Artifactory
  • • Sonatype Nexus Repository
  • • Azure Artifacts
  • • AWS CodeArtifact
  • • GitHub Package Registry

Open Source Solutions:

  • • Verdaccio (npm)
  • • DevPI (Python)
  • • Docker Registry
  • • Harbor (container registry)
  • • GitLab Package Registry

Supply Chain Security Monitoring

Continuous monitoring is essential for detecting supply chain attacks in real-time and responding before they can cause damage to your systems or data.

Monitoring and Alerting Framework

🔍 Comprehensive Monitoring Strategy

Real-Time Alerts:
  • • New high/critical vulnerabilities in dependencies
  • • Suspicious package updates or maintainer changes
  • • License compliance violations
  • • Unexpected dependency additions in PRs
  • • Failed integrity checks or signature validation
Periodic Reviews:
  • • Weekly SBOM diff analysis
  • • Monthly dependency health reports
  • • Quarterly license compliance audits
  • • Annual supply chain risk assessments
  • • Continuous security posture reviews

Incident Response for Supply Chain Attacks

🚨 Immediate Response Actions

  1. 1. Containment: Isolate affected systems and block malicious packages
  2. 2. Assessment: Identify scope of compromise and affected systems
  3. 3. Communication: Notify security team, stakeholders, and customers
  4. 4. Evidence Preservation: Collect logs, artifacts, and forensic evidence
  5. 5. Remediation: Remove malicious components and apply patches
  6. 6. Recovery: Restore systems from clean backups and verify integrity

📋 Post-Incident Actions

  • • Conduct thorough post-mortem analysis
  • • Update detection rules and monitoring
  • • Enhance code review processes
  • • Provide team training on lessons learned
  • • Update incident response procedures
  • • Share threat intelligence with community

🔗 A secure supply chain requires vigilance at every link in the dependency chain.

Secure Your Supply Chain

Propel's AI automatically detects supply chain vulnerabilities, analyzes dependencies, and ensures secure third-party code during your code review process.

Explore More

Propel AI Code Review Platform LogoPROPEL

The AI Tech Lead that reviews, fixes, and guides your development team.

SOC 2 Type II Compliance Badge - Propel meets high security standards

Company

© 2025 Propel Platform, Inc. All rights reserved.